Jump to content
Sactown Plumbing Guide

Explainer ยท Sacramento

Electric water heater 50 gallon

A 50 gallon electric water heater suits many households of three to five people. This guide covers sizing, cost, repair kits, and the elements and thermostats behind most no-heat faults.

An electric tank water heater in a garage alcove

A 50 gallon electric water heater stores 50 gallons and heats it with two electric elements, one near the top and one near the bottom. It suits a family of three to five and This Old House's water heater cost guide (updated June 2026) lists 50 gallon tanks at $700 to $1,800. Most faults trace to an element, a thermostat or a tripped safety switch. The wider topic is covered in heat pump and electric water heaters.

Is a 50 gallon electric water heater the right size?

For three to five people, usually yes. Electric tanks recover slowly, so a 50 gallon unit often matches a gas 40 gallon in what it supplies at a busy time. Check the first hour rating on the EnergyGuide label and compare it with your busiest hour, such as two showers and a dishwasher cycle.

An electric heater typically takes 1 to 2 hours to bring a full tank from cold, compared with about half an hour for gas. That recovery lag is why size matters more with electric: if the tank runs out, you wait. A household of one or two can drop to 40 or 30 gallons and save a little on standby heat loss. A bigger family, or one with a large tub, may want 65 or 80 gallons.

If your home has no gas line, an electric tank is the simplest like-for-like choice, and a heat pump water heater is an efficient alternative; see heat pump water heater cost. Sacramento electricity is supplied by SMUD in most of the city, so check your own rate plan.

What does a 50 gallon electric water heater cost?

This Old House lists 50 gallon tank water heaters at $700 to $1,800, labor for a tank install at $300 to $800, and permits and inspections at $50 to $200. A like-for-like swap in the same place with the existing circuit costs least. Moving the heater, upgrading wiring, or adding a pan, expansion tank or drain line raises the total. Sacramento prices vary, and a local specialist quotes the real price.

ItemTypical range
50 gallon tank$700 to $1,800 (This Old House)
Labor and basic install$300 to $800 (This Old House)
Permit and inspection$50 to $200 (This Old House)
Haul-away$25 to $50 (Fixr, disposal of the old unit)

For a comparison across all types, see water heater replacement cost.

How hard is it to replace an electric water heater?

Harder than it looks. The plumbing is simple, but the unit is heavy, the wiring is 240 volts, and the job needs a permit and earthquake strapping. Most households hire a local plumber. California requires a CSLB-contractor with the right California license for jobs of $1,000 or more in labor and materials, and a full replacement normally passes that.

Line drawing of an electric water heater showing two elements and thermostats

Water heaters in California must be braced, anchored or strapped against movement in an earthquake under Health and Safety Code section 19211. The City of Sacramento lists permit fees for water heaters on its building pages. A homeowner can legally do some small repairs, but a mistake with the power on can cause a shock, so the rule is to switch the breaker off and confirm with a tester before touching anything inside the access panel. Do not skip the permit and inspection: they exist so the work is checked.

If you are comparing the effort with a plumber's visit, read about hiring a plumber for water heater replacement.

Is an electric water heater repair kit worth buying?

For an old tank with a bad element or thermostat, a repair can be sensible. Fixr's water heater repair guide lists $200 to $750 to replace a heating element and $100 to $250 for a thermostat, with a plumber. Buy the kit that matches your unit's voltage, wattage and element type, and only if the tank is not leaking.

Elements are either screw-in or bolt-in, and they differ in wattage, usually 3,000 to 5,500 watts, with 4,500 common. Match the label on the heater. Do the repair only when the tank is in decent shape and under about 10 years old: if the tank has rusted or leaks, parts are wasted. If you have never opened the panels, ask a plumber.

Safe steps for the repair:

  1. Turn the breaker off, and test the wires with a voltage tester.
  2. Close the cold inlet and drain part of the tank below the element.
  3. Remove the element with an element wrench, fit the new one with a new gasket, and tighten.
  4. Refill the tank fully and open a hot tap until the water runs, before restoring power.
  5. Turn the breaker on and wait an hour or two.

Why won't an electric water heater heat after replacing the elements and thermostat?

The usual causes are that the tank was not fully refilled before power was restored, the reset button on the upper thermostat tripped, a wire is loose or on the wrong terminal, or a second fault such as a bad upper element or breaker remains. Turn the power off and check these in order.

Work through this list with the breaker off between each step:

  • Reset button. Press the red button on the upper thermostat. It trips when the heater overheats.
  • Wiring. Check that the wires are on the correct terminals and the connections are tight.
  • Elements. Test each element for resistance with a multimeter. A reading near zero or infinite is a fault.
  • Thermostats. The upper thermostat feeds power to the lower one. If the upper thermostat is bad, the lower element will never fire.
  • Breaker and supply. Check the double-pole breaker and voltage at the heater.

If the reset button trips again straight away, stop and call a plumber or an electrician. A heater that keeps tripping has a fault that can overheat. See our guide to hot water heater not working for the wider list of faults.

When should I call a plumber?

Call a plumber when the tank leaks, the reset keeps tripping, you smell burning, the wiring is unclear, or the unit is past about 12 years. Also call when the repair is more than half the price of a new heater. A local specialist can give you both numbers.

See how long a water heater lasts to judge whether a repair makes sense, and use the homepage to browse other guides.

Questions people ask

How long does it take to install a 50 gallon electric water heater?

A like-for-like swap typically takes 2 to 4 hours. Adding wiring, moving the unit or fixing a drain line can take longer. The permit inspection may be on another day, depending on how the plumber schedules it.

What should I ask before I hire someone to install an electric water heater?

Ask for the CSLB license number and check it online. Ask whether the quote includes the permit, earthquake straps, a pan and drain, and haul-away of the old tank. Ask what the manufacturer warranty covers and for how long.

Do I need to be home for an electric water heater job?

Usually yes, or someone must give access. The power and water are off for part of the visit, and the new tank needs an hour or two to heat. Ask the specialist for a time window.

How much does it cost to run a 50 gallon electric water heater?

It depends on your usage and your rate plan. Fixr's 40-gallon water heater guide lists an operating cost of $550 to $700 a year for an electric tank and $200 to $300 for a hybrid heat pump. Check your SMUD bill for your actual rate.

Sources used

Last changed